Supreme Court lawyer outburst: advocate allegedly tells CJI he lacks integrity, is escorted out
The audio-video feed of the proceedings was stopped, and other advocates reportedly urged strict action.
Written with AI assistance from the sources listed below, then checked against them and reviewed by an editor. How our newsroom works
An advocate was escorted out of a Supreme Court courtroom on Monday, 16 November, after he allegedly told Chief Justice of India Surya Kant that he lacked the integrity for the post, the Deccan Chronicle reported. This Supreme Court lawyer outburst came while he was seeking an urgent hearing on submissions about alleged corruption in the judiciary. None of the reports reviewed name him, and NIS has not done so.
What led to the Supreme Court lawyer outburst
After lunch, a three-judge bench of the Chief Justice, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana assembled, according to the paper. Before it, the lawyer said he had received no response from the CJI’s office to a communication sent on 2 November, and he pressed for an immediate hearing. NorthEast Now reported that he first apologised for raising the matter without following the prescribed mentioning procedure.
Justice Mohana objected: “You cannot mention anything like this.” Surya Kant told the lawyer, “We will see, you just wait.”
CJI Surya Kant and the remarks in court
Refusing to wait, the lawyer said, in the Deccan Chronicle’s account: “No, I would not wait. You cannot sit in that chair. You do not deserve it. You do not have the integrity for that.” Security personnel then escorted him out of the courtroom after the bench called for them.
Proceedings were muted afterwards. NorthEast Now reported that the court stopped its live feed, and The Logical Indian said the bench muted it after the remarks. Reports differ slightly on the exact wording of the lawyer’s words, so NIS quotes only the Deccan Chronicle version.
Contempt case and the Bar’s reaction
He was reportedly upset over a contempt case against him. The Logical Indian tied his frustration to a 15-day wait for a reply on that matter, while the Deccan Chronicle described his submissions as concerning alleged corruption in the judiciary. Neither spells out the details of that allegation, which remains his claim.
Other advocates in the courtroom reportedly urged the bench to initiate strict action over his conduct, the Deccan Chronicle said. Members of the Bar likewise called for disciplinary action, per The Logical Indian.
Urgent hearing request and what happens next
Mentioning of matters for urgent hearing was under way when the exchange began, NorthEast Now reported. Justice Mohana objected to the manner in which the lawyer raised the issue, remarking that such comments were inappropriate during court proceedings.
Whether the court will start contempt or disciplinary proceedings after the Supreme Court lawyer outburst is not stated in any report reviewed, and none carries an order or statement from the court. Nor do they say what became of his request for an urgent hearing. Elsewhere in the top court, NIS has covered the RBI’s review plea on Yes Bank AT1 bonds and the INDIA bloc application on SIR.
The episode puts courtroom decorum and the mentioning of urgent matters in focus at the country's top court. The Chief Justice's bench has yet to say whether it will act against a lawyer who also says his papers on alleged judicial corruption went unanswered, a claim the reports do not substantiate. Any contempt or disciplinary step would be the next signal.