Central Secretariat Library: Centre allots space after Supreme Court halts shift of 8.5 lakh books
The library's existing building is to be demolished, and the court has asked whether any new premises can hold the full collection.
Written with AI assistance from the sources listed below, then checked against them and reviewed by an editor. How our newsroom works
The Central Secretariat Library will get space in a government office building in Netaji Nagar, New Delhi, Union Culture Secretary Vivek Aggarwal has said, according to a Press Trust of India report. The announcement follows a Supreme Court hearing on Monday, 16 November, in which a bench stopped the shift of about 8.5 lakh books from the 135-year-old library and questioned why the Centre was in such a hurry.
What the Supreme Court said about the Central Secretariat Library books
A bench of Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva heard the matter, listed as In Re: 135-Year-Old Library, LawBeat reported. “If you don’t want them, give it off to some other country which will at least value them then,” the bench told the Centre. ETV Bharat quoted the bench as saying: “You are just in a hurry to get done with this.”
The court said the collection could not be treated as ordinary cargo, India Legal reported. Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati appeared for the Centre, and the bench recorded the Centre’s assurance that no shifting would take place until the next hearing. The amicus, advocate Haripriya Padmanabhan, raised concerns over whether enough space had been identified for the entire collection.
Key numbers
- 8.5 lakh: the books in the collection, per LawBeat.
- 1891: the year the library was established, per India Legal.
- 3,800 sq metres: the size of the proposed temporary premises, against about 4,100 sq metres at the existing library, per LawBeat.
- 1702: the year some of the books date back to, per the PTI report carried by The CSR Journal.
- 20 November: the date of the next hearing, per LawBeat.
Netaji Nagar: the space the Centre has allotted
Aggarwal said “sufficient space has been allotted” in a General Pool Office Accommodation building at Netaji Nagar, the PTI report said. The earlier proposal before the court was different: the government had suggested moving the library temporarily to Block-2, India Legal reported.
The reports reviewed do not say whether the Netaji Nagar building is the same as the temporary premises discussed in court. LawBeat said the library must move because the existing building is to be demolished.
Temporary premises and the court’s questions
The proposed temporary premises measure around 3,800 sq metres, LawBeat reported, which is smaller than the library’s present floor area. That gap is why the amicus asked whether the whole collection would fit. Bhati also asked the bench to look at a related library at RK Puram separately, India Legal said.
Background: other Supreme Court matters
The same court is also hearing political cases, and NIS has covered how the INDIA bloc sought Supreme Court permission to serve 48 questions on the Election Commission.
What happens next
The Central Secretariat Library matter returns to the Supreme Court on 20 November, and the Centre has to show that the new building can hold the whole collection. Until then no book moves. The reports give no floor area for the Netaji Nagar building and no date for the shift.
The books cannot move until at least 20 November, so the Centre has to show a building that fits the full collection before the court lets the shift go ahead. The gap between the 3,800 square metre temporary premises and the library's present floor area of about 4,100 square metres is the point the amicus raised, and it is likely to be tested at the next hearing.
Named in this story
Sources
- Central Vista: Supreme Court records Centre's assurance not to move 135-year-old library till November 20 (LawBeat)
- Show some respect to books: Supreme Court pulls up Centre over shifting of 8.5 lakh books (India Legal)
- Show some respect to these books: SC pauses shift of Central Secretariat Library collection (ETV Bharat)
- Central Secretariat Library relocation confirmed (PTI report, The CSR Journal)