Yes Bank AT-1 bonds: RBI seeks Supreme Court review of ruling that struck down Rs 8,415 crore write-down
The RBI argues the court did not adequately consider its Basel III Master Circular and has asked for a stay while the review is heard.
Written with AI assistance from the sources listed below, then checked against them and reviewed by an editor. How our newsroom works
The RBI wants the Supreme Court to look again. The central bank has filed a review of the 15 October judgment that struck down Yes Bank’s Rs 8,415-crore write-down of additional tier-1 (AT-1) bonds, Mint reported on Monday, 16 November. According to the court’s website, the filing is dated 13 November. The dispute over the Yes Bank AT-1 bonds goes back to the lender’s rescue in March 2020.
What the RBI review petition argues
In its plea, the RBI said the court did not adequately consider its Basel III Master Circular governing AT-1 bonds and their loss-absorption mechanism, Mint reported. It wants an open-court hearing. It has also asked for a stay on the operation of the judgment while the review plea is considered.
Yes Bank filed its own review petition on 13 November, making it the second party to seek one, according to Mint. IANS reported that the lender disclosed that petition days before the RBI’s filing appeared on the court website.
Key numbers
- Rs 8,415 crore: the AT-1 bonds written down by the administrator on 14 March 2020, per Mint.
- Rs 3,000 crore and Rs 5,415 crore: the two issuances, from December 2016 and October 2017, per Mint.
- 15 October and 13 November: the judgment date and the date both review petitions were filed.
- 240-250 basis points: the estimated cut to the bank’s Common Equity Tier-1 ratio if the bonds were reinstated, per Mint.
Yes Bank AT-1 bonds: what the court held
A bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih upheld the Bombay High Court ruling on 15 October 2026, Mint reported. It held that “the administrator of YES Bank could not write down the bonds after the final reconstruction scheme became effective on 13 March 2020”, IANS said.
The bench also observed that the government had removed from the approved scheme “a provision that expressly authorised such a write-down, making the action beyond the administrator’s powers”. The Bombay High Court had quashed the write-down in January 2023.
AT-1 bond write-off: the bondholders’ side
Axis Trustee Services represents the bondholders. It went to the Bombay High Court in May 2020 against the write-off, IANS reported. After the October judgment, the trustee sought restoration of the bonds and the rights attached to them, including reinstatement in depository and exchange records. The reports reviewed carry no response from the bondholders to the two review petitions.
What happens next
The court must now decide whether the grounds raised by the RBI and Yes Bank are sufficient to warrant a review, Mint reported. Article 137 of the Constitution allows a review only on limited grounds, such as an error apparent on the face of the record. Such petitions are generally heard in chambers by the same bench that passed the original judgment, so the RBI’s request for an open-court hearing in the Yes Bank AT-1 bonds case is a departure from the usual route. Another matter is due before the same court on 17 November: the Rahul Gandhi SIR plea.
The bonds were written down to zero in 2020, and the October judgment opened the way for their restoration. Yes Bank has estimated that reinstating them could cut its Common Equity Tier-1 ratio by around 240-250 basis points. A stay, if granted, would pause that process while the court decides whether to reopen the case.
Named in this story
Sources
- RBI moves review plea in Supreme Court against Yes Bank AT-1 bond ruling (Mint via TradingView)
- RBI moves Supreme Court to review verdict setting aside YES Bank AT-1 bond write-off (IANS via Punjab Kesari)
- RBI Seeks Review of Supreme Court Judgment on Rs 8,415 Crore YES Bank AT-1 Bond Write-Off (Hellobanker)