Shiv Sena dispute: Shinde faction tells Supreme Court dissent is not defection under Tenth Schedule
Senior advocate Dhruv Mehta told a three-judge bench that skipping a party meeting does not amount to giving up membership, and arguments resume on Wednesday.
Written with AI assistance from the sources listed below, then checked against them and reviewed by an editor. How our newsroom works
The Eknath Shinde faction told the Supreme Court on Tuesday that dissent is not defection, as the Shiv Sena dispute came up for hearing before a bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant, according to ThePrint’s PTI report. Senior advocate Dhruv Mehta argued that MLAs who opposed the Uddhav Thackeray-led leadership in June 2022 did not leave the party. Arguments continue on Wednesday.
Shiv Sena dispute: what the Shinde faction argued
The bench of Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana was told by Mehta, who appears for Shinde, now Maharashtra’s Deputy Chief Minister, and other MLAs, that the dissenting legislators “did not abandon the Shiv Sena but were seeking to restore the party’s original ideological identity and political alignment.”
Mehta said the anti-defection provisions are meant to curb defections and horse-trading, not to suppress differences within a party. In sum, he said: “Our idea is, dissent is not defection as this is not the purport of the Tenth Schedule,” LiveLaw reported.
Key numbers and dates
- 10 January 2024: the date of the Maharashtra Speaker’s decision declining to disqualify the Shinde faction’s MLAs, which the lead plea challenges.
- 21 June 2022: the date of the legislative party meeting at the centre of the disqualification petitions, per LiveLaw.
- 12:30 and 12:31 PM: the meeting start and the time of the WhatsApp text that Mehta cited.
- 1999 and 2018: the years of the party constitution and its changed structure that Mehta traced.
- Three judges: the bench hearing the matter.
Background: two pleas and the 2022 split
The lead plea, filed by Sunil Prabhu of the Thackeray faction, challenges the Speaker’s decision of 10 January 2024. A connected plea filed by Uddhav Thackeray challenges the Election Commission’s decision to recognise the Shinde faction as the official party and allot it the symbol, ThePrint reported. Mehta told the court that the then Shiv Sena leadership severed its pre-poll alliance and formed the Maha Vikas Aghadi government with the Congress and the NCP.
In August 2022, LiveLaw reported that senior advocates Kapil Sibal and AM Singhvi argued for the Thackeray group that the rebels had violated the chief whip and stood disqualified. NIS has covered other recent Supreme Court matters, including the Karthigai Deepam appeal and the Form 6 SIR hearing.
What the lawyers said about the meeting
Mehta argued that skipping a legislative party meeting cannot count as voluntarily giving up membership. He said the disqualification petitions rely on a call to a meeting issued by Sunil Prabhu, which he described as different from a whip, and that no resolution was passed.
He also alleged that a WhatsApp text went to Shinde’s personal assistant at 12:31 PM, after the meeting had begun at 12:30. On the attendance register, Mehta said, the petitioners are inconsistent: they say the faction defied the whip by staying away, yet cite signatures that he called “fabricated.” The Speaker, he submitted, had held the register unreliable. The reports reviewed do not carry the Thackeray faction’s reply to these points.
What happens next in the case
Arguments will continue on Wednesday, LiveLaw reported. The court has to decide whether the MLAs incurred disqualification under the Tenth Schedule, and the Election Commission plea is listed before the same bench. No verdict date has been reported, so the Thackeray faction’s response is the next thing to watch.
The ruling on the Tenth Schedule could decide how far MLAs can dissent from party leadership without losing their seats, and whether the Election Commission's recognition of the Shinde faction stands. The Thackeray faction's reply is still to come, so the outcome is open.
Named in this story
Sources
- Dissent not defection, MLAs may disagree with leadership: Shinde faction to SC over Shiv Sena row (PTI via ThePrint)
- Shiv Sena Dispute: Dissent Not Defection, Skipping Party Meeting Doesn't Mean Giving Up Membership (LiveLaw, 18 November 2026)
- Dissent Can't Trigger Disqualification: Eknath Shinde Shiv Sena Faction To SC (ETV Bharat)
- Supreme Court Hears Preliminary Arguments (LiveLaw, 3 August 2022)