Delhi Police affidavit tells Supreme Court reel-makers are not journalists under its protest order
The police say the court's direction was not meant to exempt reel-makers, social media influencers or unruly elements, and deny seizing any journalist's equipment.
Written with AI assistance from the sources listed below, then checked against them and reviewed by an editor. How our newsroom works
A Delhi Police affidavit filed in the Supreme Court says protections the court ordered for journalists do not extend to “so-called reel-makers” and social media influencers, Bar and Bench reported on Wednesday. The police were answering petitions from media bodies about how officers treated reporters covering the Cockroach Janata Party protests in New Delhi in October. They have asked the court to dismiss the petitions.
What the Delhi Police affidavit says
The Supreme Court said on 11 October that lawyers, journalists and other professionals should not be hindered in their professional duties. The police say that direction “does not, and was not intended to, exempt the so-called reel-makers and social media influencers”, per Bar and Bench. The Wire, citing a LiveLaw report, said the affidavit was submitted by Joint Commissioner of Police Surrender Kumar.
On who counts as a journalist, the police propose a test of purpose. “The predominant intent behind the activity may be the decisive factor,” the affidavit states, as quoted by Free Press Journal. It also accepts that lawful news gathering extends to freelancers, citizens and digital creators, and that this cannot be denied only because someone lacks a press card or PIB accreditation. Such creators remain subject to general law and police directions.
Key numbers
- 4: petitioner bodies, namely the Network of Women in Media, India, the Free Speech Collective, the Delhi Union of Journalists and the Kerala Union of Working Journalists, per Bar and Bench.
- 11 October: date of the Supreme Court order the petitioners rely on.
- 45 minutes: time after which three Indian Express reporters were released once their credentials were verified, per Free Press Journal.
- About 20 minutes: how long Paranjoy Guha Thakurta says he was driven around before being released about half a kilometre away.
Journalists named after the Cockroach Janata Party protest
The protests demanded the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar over alleged irregularities in the special intensive revision of electoral rolls. NIS has covered the same exercise in Uttarakhand.
The affidavit addresses several journalists by name. Ryan Thomas of The Caravan says he was assaulted and detained on 11 October. The police deny this and say “He was merely removed from the site in exercise of the statutory powers vested in the police authorities”. Thakurta says he was not taken to a police station, and the police deny any illegal detention. On equipment, the affidavit says “no material or article was seized from any journalist”.
What the Free Speech Collective and other petitioners argue
The petitioners approached the court between 11 and 14 October, according to The Wire, alleging police misconduct against journalists. The Wire reports that the police admitted journalists were “inadvertently” removed, which it attributes to “misidentification”. It also notes that the police guidelines of 5 October asked for valid identity cards or PIB or DIP accreditation, which it says left out independent and multimedia journalists. The police call those guidelines “facilitative and precautionary”.
What happens next for the Delhi Police affidavit
None of the three reports gives a date for the next hearing. The court will have to decide whether the Delhi Police affidavit, which leans on PIB accreditation rules and Press Council of India guidelines, sets the right line between reporters and content creators at a protest site. Until it rules, the 11 October direction stands as written, and the petitioners will contest how it applied on the ground in India‘s capital.
The affidavit asks the court to settle who counts as a journalist when police clear a protest, a question that affects freelancers and digital reporters without press accreditation. Police guidelines issued on 5 October required valid identity cards or PIB accreditation, which The Wire says left out independent journalists. A ruling would set the rule for future protests in Delhi.
Named in this story
Sources
- Reel-makers can't claim benefit of Supreme Court order protecting journalists during protests: Delhi Police (Bar and Bench)
- Delhi Police Tells Supreme Court Social Media Reel-Makers Cannot Claim Same Protections As Journalists During Protests (Free Press Journal)
- Delhi Police Tells Supreme Court Protections Meant for Journalists Do Not Extend to 'Reel-Makers' (The Wire)