Pannun lawsuit: India calls it baseless as a US court sends summonses for Doval and Goel to Delhi courts
The US court said the standard route through India's central authority had been attempted but rejected, so the papers are headed to three Delhi courts.
Written with AI assistance from the sources listed below, then checked against them and reviewed by an editor. How our newsroom works
India has rejected the Pannun lawsuit as baseless, after a US federal court asked Delhi courts to serve summonses on National Security Adviser Ajit Doval and former Research and Analysis Wing chief Samant Goel, The Wire reported. Ministry of External Affairs spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal restated India’s position on Friday, 20 November.
Pannun lawsuit: what the US court has ordered
Judge Katherine Failla of the US District Court for the Southern District of New York granted Gurpatwant Singh Pannun’s request on 9 November, according to The Wire. She accepted his argument that Article 19 of the Hague Convention on the Service Abroad of Judicial and Extrajudicial Documents would allow the summonses to be served through the Indian judiciary.
PTI reported that an order dated 13 November directed the court clerk to send the papers to the Patiala House District Court for Doval, and to the Dwarka and Tis Hazari district courts for Goel, in a report carried by Hans India. The order said the standard route through India’s central authority had been attempted but rejected. Last month the court tried a diplomatic note from the State Department to the Indian Embassy in Washington.
What MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said
“I had stated from this very platform that we reject such baseless lawsuits. That continues to be our position on the matter,” Jaiswal said on Friday, The Wire reported.
On 10 November, India had called Pannun’s allegations “fabricated and malicious” and dismissed the suit as frivolous, India Blooms reported. Jaiswal said then that a request to serve judicial documents in India “can only be routed through India’s designated central authority that is the Ministry of Law and Justice”. The reports NIS reviewed carried no comment from Doval or Goel.
Key numbers
- 2024: the year Pannun filed the civil suit, per The Wire.
- 50: unnamed individuals also named in the suit, per The Wire.
- 9 November: the date Failla granted the service request, per The Wire.
- 13 November: the date of the order directing the clerk to send the papers, per PTI via Hans India.
- Three: the Delhi district courts named in the order, per PTI.
Background: the civil suit and the criminal case
Pannun is a US and Canadian citizen and general counsel of Sikhs for Justice. His suit names the Indian government, Doval, Goel, a former RAW officer identified as Yadav, Nikhil Gupta and the unnamed individuals, and accuses them of conspiring to kill him, The Wire said. India rejects the claims. The Wire noted that the separate US criminal case over the alleged plot is distinct from the civil suit. NIS reported on the sentencing of Nikhil Gupta in that criminal case.
What happens next for the Pannun lawsuit
The reports reviewed by NIS do not say whether the Delhi courts have received the papers or when they will act. India’s stated position is that service must go through the Ministry of Law and Justice, so the next step in the Pannun lawsuit is whether any Delhi court takes up the US request.
The order tests India's insistence that service of papers must go through the Ministry of Law and Justice, because the US court has chosen a different path through Delhi courts. It keeps a civil suit naming India's national security adviser alive in a US court while the separate criminal case over the alleged plot also moves forward.