Justice Yashwant Varma says resignation ended removal bid and is not an admission of guilt
The judge says his 9 April resignation took effect by its own force, citing a 1978 Constitution Bench ruling, while the inquiry report tabled on 12 August found all three charges proved.
Written with AI assistance from the sources listed below, then checked against them and reviewed by an editor. How our newsroom works
Justice Yashwant Varma has told Parliament that his resignation as a high court judge ended the proceedings to remove him, and that it does not mean he accepts any wrongdoing. In a letter to Lok Sabha Secretary General Utpal Kumar Singh, dated 10 September and circulated among MPs on Thursday, he said he is innocent of the allegations over burnt currency notes found at his official residence.
What the letter says
Varma wrote that “Upon my resignation, proceedings directed towards my removal from office did not survive and cannot be continued”, as ThePrint reported from PTI. He argued that the constitutional provisions on removing judges apply to sitting judges, not to those who have left office, and that any attempt to remove him now would be without constitutional foundation.
He cited Article 217(1)(a) of the Constitution and a 1978 Constitution Bench ruling of the Supreme Court in Union of India vs Gopal Chandra Mishra. By that reading, a high court judge’s resignation takes effect by its own force and needs no acceptance from the President or any other authority. Deccan Herald reported that he also said he has neither drawn salary nor received any facility, allowance, benefit or perquisite of a high court judge since he resigned.
Key numbers
- 10 September: the date of Varma’s letter to the Lok Sabha Secretary General, per ThePrint.
- 9 April: the day he tendered his resignation to the President with immediate effect, per Daily Jagran.
- 12 August: the day the inquiry committee’s report was tabled in Parliament, per ThePrint.
- Three of three: the charges the committee found proved, per Deccan Herald.
- Nearly 150: the MPs who moved the notice seeking his removal, per ThePrint.
Cash discovery row: what the inquiry found
The three-member committee was set up by Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla under the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968. It found all three charges against Varma proved. Deccan Herald described them as interfering with evidence, giving an evasive explanation of the sequence of events, and the discovery of unexplained cash at his residence.
Varma rejects the findings. In his 9 April letter to the panel he wrote that it “defies ordinary logic and common sense” that he would store cash in a place accessible to several people. The earlier Supreme Court clash over contempt of the bench is covered in our report on the Pravin Singhal notice.
Varma resignation: not yet notified
ThePrint said the resignation has not yet been formally notified. Under the Constitution, high court and Supreme Court judges leave office either by resigning or through removal by Parliament for proved misbehaviour or incapacity. The open question is whether a removal notice signed by nearly 150 MPs can still be acted on once the judge has resigned.
What happens next for justice Yashwant Varma
The letter is now with MPs. The reports reviewed by NIS do not say whether the Lok Sabha Secretariat or Speaker Om Birla will reply, or when the resignation will be notified. Any further step would rest with Parliament.
The letter asks Parliament a legal question: can proceedings under the Judges (Inquiry) Act continue once a judge has resigned. The answer decides whether a report that found all three charges proved leads to a removal vote or lapses with the resignation, and it will guide how future inquiries treat judges who quit mid-process.